No Pre-Boil Mac & Cheese- Crock Pot Challenge #3

/, Crock Pot Meals, Dinner, Food, Recipes, Side Dishes/No Pre-Boil Mac & Cheese- Crock Pot Challenge #3

No Pre-Boil Mac & Cheese- Crock Pot Challenge #3

*This is the 3rd of 10 Crock Pot Recipes I am trying between now and the end of February for the Peanut Butter Fingers Blog Crock Pot Challenge.*

Have you tried this pasta before?   As a vegetarian (pescatarian), I’m always looking for good ways to sneak extra protein into my diet.  This pasta has 10+ extra grams of protein depending on your meal size.  It’s an easy way to bulk up any pasta meal.



And you can hide it in Mac and Cheese.  Yum– Mac and Cheese is one of my favorites.  It’s exactly what I go for when the weather goes downhill or I don’t feel good. Talk about a “southern comfort!”


I’ve made the cheesy pasta goodness in the Crock Pot before, but it always involved pre-cooking the noodles in a separate pot of boiling water.  In my mind that is just more work and more mess.  Isn’t the Crock Pot all about making cooking easy? So when I saw a recipe on Pinterest that called for dumping uncooked macaroni noodles in your Crock Pot I was intrigued.  Would it work?

Here is a link to the original recipe I found on Pinterest from the Family Fresh Meals blog.  I followed the recipe pretty closely, so I need to give it a proper shout out!

I considered this an experiment of sorts.  I was interested to see if the noodles would properly cook and not be hard.  The good news is they cooked, the bad news is I think I used way too many low fat products and the end result was just a slight bit dry.  The hubs said I was being too hard on myself and it tasted really good.  I would recommend trying to cut the fat in some of the cheese, but not using all low fat products.  Hopefully that would make it a little less dry.

If you are looking for a low fat Mac and Cheese, I found also found this recipe on Pinterest from Fitness magazine to make Mac and Cheese with greek yogurt.  It’s not a Crock Pot recipe, but it may be a better way to cut calories.

Let me know if you try it.

AND- If you want a really awesome, tried and true, full fat, Crock Pot Mac and Cheese recipe, try this one – click HERE.  Yes, you have to precook noodles.  But this Paula Dean Mac and Cheese and is a go-to recipe for our Thanksgiving. It works like a charm.  Don’t count the calories though… it’s ridiculous.

As I mentioned, my version was an experiment so I just thought I’d offer you options Smile

This is what I used:


1 box macaroni

4 tbs butter  (margarine*)

4 cups shredded cheese (low fat*)

4 oz cream cheese, cubed (low fat*)

2 cups of milk (low fat*)

12oz can evaporated milk (low fat*)

1/4 cup sour cream (low fat*)

1 tsp salt

1 tsp pepper

1/2 tsp nutmeg

1 tsp onion powder

1 tbs dry mustard

* Something should be full fat to give it more cream—woops!


Spray Crock Pot with Pam—I didn’t do this and mine stuck!

Turn on Crock Pot.  Heat and whisk milk, evaporated milk, butter, sour cream, cream cheese and spices until it’s not as lumpy.


Add uncooked noodles


Put cheese on top but don’t stir.  It mixes down through the Mac and Cheese as it cooks.


Cut on low for 3-4 hours.  This is one you want to do when you are home.  Stir occasionally to get the crunchy outer crust throughout the pot.  It actually makes it feel like a baked Mac & Cheese.


Serve and Enjoy!




What’s your favorite Mac & Cheese recipe?

Do your cooking experiments sometimes end up a little off?[/fusion_builder_column][/fusion_builder_row][/fusion_builder_container]

By | 2017-08-15T14:04:33-04:00 January 31st, 2013|All Vegetarian, Crock Pot Meals, Dinner, Food, Recipes, Side Dishes|4 Comments


  1. Debbie Shelton June 27, 2014 at 7:07 am - Reply

    You used to much macaroni . Try it again using less macaroni and see what you think. I think you’ll find that it will do much better.

    • JulieWunder June 27, 2014 at 7:19 am - Reply

      Thanks Debbie! I’m going to go back and improve this recipe even more when I have some more time!

  2. Kim @ Cooking in the City February 1, 2013 at 4:42 pm - Reply

    Ahh… something new to add my to-do list. I may go all out though on full fat 🙂 I can also imagine the last hour of stirring is super dangerous- so many opportunities to taste test!

    • JulieWunder February 2, 2013 at 1:36 pm - Reply

      I agree– I can’t resist cheese 🙂

Leave A Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Copycat Panera Strawberry Caprese Salad recipe-

Be inspired!


Get healthy recipes, fitness inspiration, travel and twin antics in your inbox! 


Guaranteed to make you smile.

You have Successfully Subscribed!